Which Volunteering Activity Reads Better on a College Application?

Here’s a question with a right answer: which volunteering activity reads better on a college application?
- Weeding and mulching a community garden every week. Same space, same day, same time, same gloves, same people, same volunteer coordinator, same everything, for four years. Total: 200 hours.
- A three-week summer trip with a reputable nonprofit, working 10 hours a day on something exciting and glamorous (think cleaning oil off shivering penguins), and spending a fair amount of money to go. Total: 200 hours.
That last detail should tip you off. Colleges don’t expect students to bankroll expensive activities to impress them, and they’re usually more put off by what that implies than excited by the story. Your teen shouldn’t have to spend money to earn a place at a great college.

Why the “boring” option wins
It may not seem like it at first, but that first activity is really hard to claim. Ask any friend who started and quit a weekly commitment like volunteering at the Ronald McDonald House. One week off for tests becomes two weeks off (tests again; that excuse never runs out), which becomes… you can guess the rest.
It’s hard to keep showing up to the same place week after week, especially if it isn’t a social volunteering club like Key Club, working alongside people who aren’t your age, doing work that isn’t instantly gratifying. Colleges know this too, which is why they have a clear preference for steady, multi-year volunteering commitments in the community.

About that amazing volunteer trip: please don’t misunderstand me. I said it reads poorly, but it may still be a life-changing, unmissable experience. If you feel moved to go, go! Eat new foods, talk to new people, take lots of pictures. But for the rest of your volunteering, I hope you’ll choose the sustained-commitment route.
Glamorous volunteering is a bit of an oxymoron anyway.

What a volunteer manager looks for
I once sat down with Nancy Carlton, then the volunteer manager at the Los Angeles County Arboretum & Botanic Garden in Arcadia, to ask what kinds of students she’d want me to send her. When she described the student she’d staff in the gardens, gift shop, or membership office, she described a rare bird:
- Someone who brings fresh energy to the task every week, without turning to their phone.
- Someone who communicates with peers and supervisors regularly and independently (no parent emails).
- Someone dependable who shows up to every shift, every week.
Nancy told me how exciting it is to meet a genuine, committed 14-year-old volunteer. By now she can spot the ones who will stay all four years. Some become leaders among the volunteers or bring special skills and projects that make the Arboretum even better.

I think it’s really impressive when teenagers meet those expectations. And, parents, let’s admit it can be tough for us adults too.
Admissions offices are full of human adults who share that perspective. They read applications asking: if this student comes to our campus, what kind of community member will they become? They want to see volunteering that shows a student’s potential to make a difference with their education.
The good news is that your teen gets to choose. I help my students find volunteering they love, so keeping the commitment for four years feels easy. Just ask my students at the Arboretum: they keep going back because they enjoy it. For more ideas, see my guide to volunteer activities for high school students and what extracurriculars look best on college applications.
Interested in volunteering at the Arboretum? See their volunteer page for current opportunities.
Free Download
The Activity Tracker
For 9th through 11th graders: log hours, roles, and wins as they happen, so four years of steady commitment are ready for the Activities List.
Get the Activity Tracker →Free. I’ll send it straight to your inbox.
Robert Powers
Founder, College Torch
Robert Powers is the founder of College Torch, a college counseling practice in Sierra Madre, California, that works with families nationwide. In 10+ years he has guided 300+ students, and 90% go to one of their top three college choices. He holds two degrees from Johns Hopkins, is a Professional Member of IECA, and co-authored a chapter in NACAC’s textbook for college counselors.
IECANACACHECAWACACM.A. Johns Hopkins
Book a free Right-Fit Call | Meet Robert | Parent group on Facebook

