College Torch logo

How to Get a Winning Teacher Recommendation

As a first-year teacher, I wrote a recommendation from a template. Here's what I wish that student had known, and how your teen can help teachers write a truly personal letter.

A version of this post was first published in The South Pasadenan in 2019.

As a former full-time public school teacher, I’m going to share something from my first year of teaching that I’m probably supposed to keep to myself: the moment a senior asked me to write his college recommendation, and what happened next.

Students raising hands in class
I hope my advice is a little more helpful than “raise your hand in class!”

My first recommendation letter

It was the first letter I had ever written for a student. He was energetic, loved to learn, and was always first to raise his hand, though he sometimes took a while to put his thoughts into words. He was autistic, and he belonged at an excellent, rigorous university that would also support his social and emotional needs. I knew exactly what I wanted to say, and I wrote a first draft that same day.

On Monday, I reread it. It was, objectively, garbage. All my precise, true, patiently observed words mostly gave the impression that he was a hassle to have in class. Not even close to what I meant.

I went to a colleague who led the Spanish program and had more than 25 years of teaching experience. I didn’t want to let this student down. Almost as if she’d been asked before, Señora was quick to help. She pulled out a USB drive, plugged it into my laptop, and copied five Word documents from a folder called TEMPLATES ALL. In order, they were named “meh1,” “meh2,” “good,” “great,” and “best in my career.”

Teacher working at a laptop
My colleague had a system, like many teachers do. Colleges know this, and many are searching for those words: “best in my career.”

She explained the system. Every student fits one of the five categories. The student’s name goes into the blanks, and the teacher takes extra care not to mix up names. Each template had a paragraph for listing the student’s activities, a section for generic adjectives like “caring” and “organized,” and a small space for special comments, if any. As long as I had the student’s resume and could roughly remember their performance and personality, Señora said, I could print and sign a letter in five to ten minutes.

I worked on different versions of my student’s letter for a few weeks, but in the end, I used Señora’s template. I felt guilty, because it was so different from how I had imagined my own favorite teachers writing my letters. But as a first-year teacher, I knew the “best in my career” template was the strongest letter that student could get from me at the time.

Student talking with a teacher
Don’t panic! There’s a lot your teen can do to help a teacher write a personal, attention-grabbing letter.

If that sounds like an unhappy ending, keep reading. As a college counselor, I now use that experience to help my students get the best possible letters from their teachers, who are, like I was, human beings doing their best. Here’s the advice I would give that student today.

Ask the right teachers, the right way

  • Time it well. Start a casual conversation with your 11th grade teachers (not 10th or 12th) in May of junior year. Tell them you’ll follow up in September, and then do it.
  • Choose wisely. First-year teachers and others with little rec-writing experience may not yet know how to write an outstanding letter, no matter how much they want to.
  • Choose your words carefully. “Could you write me a letter for the University of Maryland?” (what my student asked) is a very different question from the one I recommend: “Would you feel comfortable writing me a strong recommendation by the November 1 deadline?” Give your teacher a graceful way out if they need one.
Handwritten thank-you note
Don’t accidentally bribe your teacher! Write a kind thank-you note only after they’ve submitted your letter.

Make the letter easy to write

  • Write a one-page brag sheet. Unless your teachers limit how many letters they write (and I talk students through those situations often), they have a lot to get through, often over winter break. It’s kind and smart to help. Give your teacher a one-page resource, on paper and by email, when you ask in September. Done well, your teacher can copy words, phrases, and even whole sentences straight into the letter.
  • Include only what they should write about. Leave off what already appears elsewhere in your application, like activities, test scores, and GPA. Think about what isn’t in your application. Could your teacher mention family context that explains your performance in their class? Paint a picture of you on your best day in their classroom?
  • Give them stories. Write your brag sheet so your teacher has to abandon the template. The best recommendations tell stories. For example, describe an ethical dilemma you faced in class that your teacher may not have known about. Great stories don’t have to happen in front of the teacher. Imagine a physics teacher describing how a student used concave and convex mirrors to make a parking garage safer at a parent’s workplace. The teacher could only write that after reading it on the brag sheet.
  • Give them quotes. Offer plenty of your own words your teacher can quote. Get creative, but put them in writing.
  • Save your best work. Keep strong assignments in a folder throughout the year, and share copies from different points in the year when you ask.
  • Revise your brag sheet. Review and revise until the words blur together, then ask someone you trust to look it over.
  • Use your people. Ask your school counselor for their perspective on your recommendation plan. Depending on how stretched they are, they may be more or less available than you need, so keep a list of other people you trust for feedback: mentors, family friends, or a college counselor.
Student raising a hand
And yes, you should raise your hand in class! Ask thoughtful questions that move the discussion forward.

In the end, my student from that first year was admitted to his favorite university. But he would have gotten a much stronger, more personal letter from me if he had known how to help me help him.

Free Download

The College Admission Timeline

Know exactly when to ask for recommendations, and every other deadline from 9th grade through May 1.

Get the College Admission Timeline →

Free. I’ll send it straight to your inbox.

Robert Powers

Founder, College Torch

Robert Powers is the founder of College Torch, a college counseling practice in Sierra Madre, California, that works with families nationwide. In 10+ years he has guided 300+ students, and 90% go to one of their top three college choices. He holds two degrees from Johns Hopkins, is a Professional Member of IECA, and co-authored a chapter in NACAC’s textbook for college counselors.

IECANACACHECAWACACM.A. Johns Hopkins

Book a free Right-Fit Call  |  Meet Robert  |  Parent group on Facebook

Share the Post:

Related Posts