College Torch logo

What Extracurricular Activities Look Best on College Applications?

Colleges don't keep a list of favorite activities. What they notice is commitment over time and a description specific enough that only your teen could have written it.

Every year, parents ask me some version of the same question. “What activities should my teen be doing to look good to colleges?”

I understand why they ask. Admissions can feel like a code to crack, and a list of approved activities would be awfully convenient. That list doesn’t exist, and families who chase one tend to end up with an exhausted teen and an application that blends in.

Student with a backpack at a signpost pointing to leadership, sports, arts, research, and clubs

Isn’t there one activity colleges love?

Every few years, a new activity gets crowned as the one that impresses colleges. Research had its turn, and so did entrepreneurship. The names change, and the strategy behind them stays the same.

Admissions readers notice when a whole crop of applicants is doing the same thing for the same strategic reason. An activity chosen for how it looks usually produces a thin description, with vague verbs, no numbers, and nothing only that student could have written.

When I read a draft Activities List, I use what I call the Stranger Test. Could someone who has never met the student read each description and picture what the student did? A weekly shift at a family restaurant often passes with flying colors. A fancy summer program often fails, because the student described the program and forgot to describe themselves.

What makes any activity worth listing

These qualities apply to debate team and dishwashing equally.

Time

One activity for four years reads very differently from four activities for one year each. Every fall that a student signs up again, they’re choosing it again, and readers notice that choice. (I made the case for the steady option in my post on which volunteering activity reads better on a college application.)

Growing responsibility

Did your role grow? Maybe you started as a new member and became the person others relied on. You don’t need a title for that to count. Teaching new members and running practice when the coach is out both count as leadership.

When a title did change, the UC Application lets you show it at the start of the description, most recent first, as in “President (11-12), Member (9-10).”

Specifics

This is the quality that separates strong Activities Lists from weak ones. Can you say what you actually did? Trade “helped with” and “participated in” for the real work, such as how many kids you coached, what you built or repaired, or how much your club raised. If you can be specific, any activity makes a strong entry.

Interest you can’t fake

Readers have good instincts for whether a student cared. Students who care notice more, so they remember what changed and what was hard. A teen who took a restaurant job because the family needed the income, and grew proud of handling the Friday dinner rush, usually writes a stronger description than a teen who signed up for a pricey summer program because it looked good.

Split image of a teen working in a cafe and a teen doing lab research

Activities students forget to list

I said there’s no magic activity, and I meant it. There are a few kinds of activities students leave off because they don’t realize they count.

Jobs

Paid work is one of the most undersold entries on college applications. A teen who works 15 hours a week during the school year is holding down a real job on top of school, and colleges respect that. The job title doesn’t need to be impressive, but the description does. I wrote more about this in Do Jobs Help Your College Application?

Family responsibilities

Caring for a sibling, running the household after school, and interpreting for parents all belong on the application. The Common App even has an activity type for family responsibilities. Students who have done this work for years often leave it off because it doesn’t feel like an activity, but it counts, and readers take it seriously.

Projects your teen started

Something your teen built, taught themselves, or published counts even when no school or club sponsored it, whether that’s an app, a YouTube channel with a real topic, or a portfolio of art.

Research with a mentor

If your teen did research through a paid mentorship program, list it as research with a mentor and leave the program’s brand name out. Readers care about the work, and a brand name can read as pay-to-play.

Community and culture

Religious youth groups, cultural dance and music ensembles, martial arts training, and neighborhood projects all count. None of them needs an official sponsor.

If you’re in 9th or 10th grade

You have the biggest advantage there is, which is time. Try things because you’re curious, and keep the ones you’d miss if they disappeared. Get better at them, and take on more when the chance comes.

Please don’t join clubs to build a resume. That approach usually produces a list of strategic choices that don’t add up to a person, and admissions readers have seen thousands of those. I give you permission to quit an activity you’ve outgrown, especially if it frees up time for one you love.

Student journaling at a desk surrounded by notes and a planner

Start a log now

The details fade faster than anyone expects. By the fall of senior year, your teen won’t remember how many kids they tutored in 10th grade or what the club raised at the spring fundraiser.

So keep a running log. After a practice, shift, or event that mattered, write two sentences about what happened, with numbers when you have them. The free Activity Tracker below is built for exactly this, and when it’s time to turn those notes into polished descriptions for the Common App and the UC Application, my Dazzling Activities course walks through every field.

Your teen’s October-of-senior-year self will be very grateful.

Free Download for 9th to 11th Graders

The High School Activity Tracker

A simple template to record what your teen is doing, when, for how long, and what happened. Five minutes to set up, and it saves hours when applications open.

Get the Activity Tracker →

Free. I’ll send it straight to your inbox.

Junior or senior?

If applications are close, start with my free Activities Field Guide → It helps your teen find everything that belongs on their Activities List.

Robert Powers

Founder, College Torch

Robert Powers is the founder of College Torch, a college counseling practice in Sierra Madre, California, that works with families nationwide. In 10+ years he has guided 300+ students, and 90% go to one of their top three college choices. He holds two degrees from Johns Hopkins, is a Professional Member of IECA, and co-authored a chapter in NACAC’s textbook for college counselors.

IECANACACHECAWACACM.A. Johns Hopkins

Book a free Right-Fit Call  |  Meet Robert  |  Parent group on Facebook

Share the Post:

Related Posts