College Torch logo

College Interviews: Dos and Don’ts

Interviews are a small part of the application, but a bad one can hurt. Here's what to do, what to avoid, and how to follow up so your teen leaves a strong impression.

This post was written by Rose Wong, a Duke student, for College Torch in 2020.

A college interview lets a college get to know you through a real person connected to the school. Most interviewers are alumni, though some colleges offer interviews with admissions officers or current students, in person or by video.

Truth be told, interviews count for a small part of the application. It’s one person’s report after meeting you for 30 to 60 minutes, so it matters far less than your essays, transcript, or recommendations. That said, don’t blow it. A so-so review won’t sink a strong application, but a scathing one could.

Here are a few dos and don’ts to keep in mind.

Do

Show how much you want to be there

This may be your first interview or your eighth. Either way, show this interviewer that their college stands out on your list, and that you know exactly why. Do your research and be ready to talk about the specific programs, opportunities, and traditions that excite you. If it truly is your top choice, say so clearly. Interviewers listen for genuine enthusiasm.

Show a memorable side of yourself

Your interviewer may meet several students in one afternoon. Don’t be the one they vaguely remember when it’s time to write their report. Share what makes you you, whether it’s a robotics project that solves a real problem for your neighbors or a summer spent recording oral histories. Whatever it is, bring your passion. That’s what leaves an impression.

Practice

You want to be natural and conversational, but that doesn’t mean you skip practice, practice, practice. Interview questions aren’t things you’re asked every day, so think through your answers ahead of time. Why do you think you’re a good fit for our college? If you had an extra hour in the day, how would you spend it?

Don’t

Dress too casually

Business casual is the move. Swap the jeans and sneakers for something like a collared shirt or nice blouse with slacks, or a simple dress. You want to look put-together and feel comfortable, so the focus stays on the conversation.

Talk up (or trash) other colleges

Speak too positively about another college, and it may sound like your heart is elsewhere. Speak negatively, and it can come across as bad taste. Besides, you never know whose kid goes there. If your interviewer asks where else you’re applying, answer briefly and pivot back to your experiences, your interests, and why this college appeals to you.

Say you don’t have any questions

Near the end, your interviewer will ask, “Do you have any questions for me?” Thoughtful questions show you’re seriously considering the college. Saying no can come off as disinterest, and it wastes a chance to keep the conversation going. You may think of better questions during the interview, but always prepare a few. What was your favorite part of your time there? I’m interested in the X program; do you think it’s doable alongside a double major?

Forget to follow up

Send a short thank-you email within a day. Thank your interviewer for their time, mention something specific from your conversation, and briefly restate your interest in the college. It means something that you took the time, and it may end up in their report.

Cliché because it’s true: be yourself. Insincerity shows, and it’s hard to connect with someone who’s performing. You’re interesting and worth getting to know. Interviewing by video? Read my tips on acing a virtual college interview.

Practice Makes Confident

I run mock interviews with my students so the real one feels familiar. Curious how that works? Book a free Right-Fit Call.

Free Download

The College Admission Timeline

Interviews are just one milestone. See every deadline and decision point from 9th grade through May 1 so your teen doesn’t miss a thing.

Get the College Admission Timeline →

Free. I’ll send it straight to your inbox.

Robert Powers

Founder, College Torch

Robert Powers is the founder of College Torch, a college counseling practice in Sierra Madre, California, that works with families nationwide. In 10+ years he has guided 300+ students, and 90% go to one of their top three college choices. He holds two degrees from Johns Hopkins, is a Professional Member of IECA, and co-authored a chapter in NACAC’s textbook for college counselors.

IECANACACHECAWACACM.A. Johns Hopkins

Book a free Right-Fit Call  |  Meet Robert  |  Parent group on Facebook

Share the Post:

Related Posts