How to Research Colleges the Way I Teach My Students

Most students research colleges backwards. They start with a ranking or a name they’ve heard of, then try to figure out whether they’d like it there. The students who end up happiest do it the other way around. They figure out what they need first, then go find the colleges that offer it.
This is the process I use with my students. It works whether your teen is a curious sophomore or a senior building a list this fall.
1. Know what matters to your teen
Before opening a single website, have your teen rank what matters most to them. These are the big ones.
- Academics. Strong programs in their likely majors, and enough flexibility if they change their mind (most students do).
- Learning style. Small discussion classes with professors who know their name, or a big research university with endless options.
- Size and setting. City, suburb, college town, or rural campus, and how far from home.
- Cost. What your family can actually pay, which may be very different from the sticker price.
- Community. The social scene, the clubs, the politics, and whether students like your teen thrive there. For LGBTQ+ students, that includes these eight big things.
2. Go beyond the brochure
College websites are marketing. They’re useful, but they’re written to make every school sound like a fit. These sources tell you more.
- The Common Data Set. Search the college’s name plus “Common Data Set.” It shows admit rates, test score ranges, how much the college weighs grades, essays, and demonstrated interest, and how generous its financial aid is.
- The Net Price Calculator. Every college has one on its website. Fifteen minutes with your tax return gives you a real estimate of what you’d pay.
- The course catalog and department pages. Look at actual classes in your teen’s intended major. Are they exciting? Taught by professors or mostly graduate students?
- Student voices. The student newspaper, student organizations’ social media, and virtual tours led by students show what daily life is really like.
- The Annual Security Report. Every college publishes one under the Clery Act. It’s one of the most honest documents a college puts out.
3. Get personal
Nothing replaces talking to people. Visit if you can (here’s how to make the most of a campus visit). Attend a virtual information session. Email the regional admissions officer with a real question. And ask to talk with a current student in your teen’s area of interest. One honest conversation can move a college up or off the list in 20 minutes.
4. Build a balanced list
Once your teen has a set of colleges they really like, sort them by your teen’s chance of getting in. I use four tiers with my students. The percentages are my judgment for one student, in their own context and intended major, so they aren’t the same as a college’s published admit rate. The Common Data Set from step 2 helps here, since it shows the grades and scores of admitted students.
- Moonshot. Under a 10% chance. These are wonderful to try for, and no one should count on them.
- Reach. A 10% to 25% chance.
- Target. A 25% to 75% chance.
- Likely. More than a 75% chance. When a likely college also awards merit aid your teen could earn, I call it a scholarship school.
The rule I care about most is that every college on the list, especially the likely ones, should be a place your teen would be happy to attend. A likely college your teen would dread isn’t really a backup plan.
5. Keep it organized
Research falls apart when it lives in 40 browser tabs. Keep one spreadsheet with each college’s basics, academics, campus life, admissions numbers, net price, and your teen’s own rating. By senior fall, you’ll have a list built on evidence and a teen who knows why every college is on it.
Aim for a list your teen is excited about from top to bottom, so every acceptance is good news.
Free Toolkit
Every research resource, plus the organizer
My free College Research Toolkit gives your teen a curated list of every resource worth using, by category, plus a ready-made spreadsheet to compare and rate each college.
Send Me the Free Toolkit →Free. I’ll send it straight to your inbox.
Keep reading
Robert Powers
Founder, College Torch
Robert Powers is the founder of College Torch, a college counseling practice in Sierra Madre, California, that works with families nationwide. In 10+ years he has guided 300+ students, and 90% go to one of their top three college choices. He holds two degrees from Johns Hopkins, is a Professional Member of IECA, and co-authored a chapter in NACAC’s textbook for college counselors.
IECANACACHECAWACACM.A. Johns Hopkins
Book a free Right-Fit Call | Meet Robert | Parent group on Facebook

