What the Pandemic Changed in College Admissions, and What It Didn’t
Updated November 2026. I first wrote this post in spring 2020, when the pandemic had just upended high school. Here’s how things have shaken out since.
The pandemic shook up college admissions more than anything in a generation. Some of those changes stuck, some reversed, and some of the most important things never changed at all. Here’s what families need to know now.

What changed
1. Testing policies swung away, then partly back
In 2020, nearly every college went test-optional, and the College Board discontinued SAT Subject Tests the following year. Since 2024, many highly selective colleges have reinstated their SAT or ACT requirement, including most of the Ivy League, MIT, Stanford, and Caltech. At the same time, hundreds of colleges remain test-optional, and the University of California and Cal State systems don’t consider SAT or ACT scores at all. The result is a patchwork, so check each college’s current policy on its admissions website every year.
My advice: if your teen’s list includes test-required or test-recommended colleges, plan to test. If every college on the list is test-optional or test-free, testing becomes a strategic choice we make together based on their scores and goals.
2. The COVID essay became the Challenges and Circumstances question
The Common App added an optional COVID-19 question in 2020, broadened it to “community disruption” a year later, and in 2025 replaced it with an optional “Challenges and Circumstances” question. It’s a short space (up to 250 words) for serious circumstances that affected your teen’s education, like a family responsibility, a lack of a quiet place to study, or a disruption outside their control. It’s not for every student, and it’s not a second Personal Statement.
3. Online and outside coursework is here to stay
The pandemic made schools more comfortable with online learning. Many students now take for-credit courses at a local community college, through dual enrollment, or from accredited online providers, sometimes to get ahead in math or a world language. School policies vary on whether those courses appear on the transcript, so ask your school counselor before you enroll, not after.
4. Virtual options stuck around
Virtual information sessions, online tours, and video interviews are now a permanent part of the college search. They’re a great way to explore far-away colleges before deciding which ones are worth visiting in person. See my tips for acing a virtual interview.

What didn’t change
1. Time management is still a student’s first survival skill
Online coursework makes this even more important. The goal isn’t just to finish the work on time; it’s to learn and retain the material your teen will need in senior year and in college. If time management is a weakness, start practicing accountability with a planner that includes specific times for specific tasks.
2. Reading still matters
Colleges want students who read. So do employers, and so do the people your teen will someday lead. Reading a variety of challenging books regularly should be part of a student’s identity, not just their homework. Need ideas? Try my lists of books for teens who loved Freakonomics and dystopian novels for middle schoolers.
3. Teachers still need brag sheets
Teachers who write recommendations are overloaded, and it’s tempting to fall back on templates. Your teen can help by giving each recommender a short resource with stories, examples, and work from their class. A specific memory is far more useful to a teacher than a list of accomplishments.
4. Starting essays early still pays off
The summer before senior year is the best time to work on the UC Personal Insight Questions and the Common App Personal Statement. Your teen doesn’t want to be writing first drafts in the fall, when college-specific supplements start piling up.
5. Selective admissions are as competitive as ever
Applications to the most selective colleges surged during the test-optional years and haven’t come back down. That’s why a balanced list, with moonshot, reach, target, and likely colleges that all fit your teen, matters more than ever.
Free Download
The College Admission Timeline
Make sure your teen has a strong college plan and doesn’t miss a milestone, from 9th grade through May 1.
Get the College Admission Timeline →Free. I’ll send it straight to your inbox.
Robert Powers
Founder, College Torch
Robert Powers is the founder of College Torch, a college counseling practice in Sierra Madre, California, that works with families nationwide. In 10+ years he has guided 300+ students, and 90% go to one of their top three college choices. He holds two degrees from Johns Hopkins, is a Professional Member of IECA, and co-authored a chapter in NACAC’s textbook for college counselors.
IECANACACHECAWACACM.A. Johns Hopkins
Book a free Right-Fit Call | Meet Robert | Parent group on Facebook

