Top Tips for a Winning College Essay
Ahh, the big essay. Or rather, essays: the Common App Personal Statement goes to every college that uses the Common App, many colleges add their own supplemental questions, and if your teen is applying to the University of California, there are the UC Personal Insight Questions too.
Students are often intimidated by college essays because they’re so open-ended. Which prompt should I pick? What should I say? What do they want to know? Anxious questions aside, the purpose of the essay is simple: to show the admissions reader who you are beyond the scores, numbers, and letters, which can hardly define a person.
Here are my top tips to make the process much easier.

Start early
Rushed writing is rarely good writing. You need time to figure out which prompt connects with you and which life experience best shows who you are. Starting early also lets you change direction if you think of something better, or if an idea doesn’t work as well on paper as it did in your head.
Good writing needs time to ferment. Write a draft, let it sit for a bit, and come back with fresh eyes. Do that a few more times. You’ll find new edits and angles after some distance.
Ask for feedback, but not too much
Along the way, ask one or two people you trust for feedback. A fresh perspective can reveal room for improvement you couldn’t see. But there’s such a thing as too many editors, especially for personal writing. Too many opinions lead to contradictory, confusing feedback that dilutes the most important thing in the essay: your voice.
Answer the prompt
One of admissions readers’ biggest pet peeves is an essay that doesn’t answer the question. Be creative, but make sure your essay doesn’t stray from what the prompt is asking.
Show us you’re human
Don’t repeat the accomplishments already on your Activities List or transcript, or use the essay to relive your greatest moments of glory. This part of the application is where you show the reader your human side: the emotions, challenges, mistakes, and unexpected triumphs.
One well-known essay by a Johns Hopkins applicant is about the surprisingly hard task of tying the string on bakery boxes at her job. She turns a seemingly minor experience into something significant by showing what the knot came to mean to her: perseverance, patience, and, in a playful twist, string theory.
Be careful with humor
The admissions reader may not share your sense of humor, or your friends’ and family’s. Jokes on the page often fall flat or come across as snarky. A light touch can work, but don’t let humor replace honesty. Focus on being genuine and letting the reader in.
Writing the UC essays? Start with my 5 tips for stellar UC essays and my guide to all eight prompts.
Free Download
The UC Essay Planning Guide
Applying to any UC campus? See what UC readers look for in all eight Personal Insight Questions, so there are no surprises.
Get the UC Essay Planning Guide →Free. I’ll send it straight to your inbox.
Robert Powers
Founder, College Torch
Robert Powers is the founder of College Torch, a college counseling practice in Sierra Madre, California, that works with families nationwide. In 10+ years he has guided 300+ students, and 90% go to one of their top three college choices. He holds two degrees from Johns Hopkins, is a Professional Member of IECA, and co-authored a chapter in NACAC’s textbook for college counselors.
IECANACACHECAWACACM.A. Johns Hopkins
Book a free Right-Fit Call | Meet Robert | Parent group on Facebook

