Should You Take the SAT or ACT? A Counselor’s Guide for 2026 and Beyond

A few years ago, my answer for many students was “probably not.” Today, my answer is “probably yes, at least once.”
Test-optional isn’t going away. Most four-year colleges in the U.S. still let students apply without scores. But since 2024, a long list of highly selective colleges has brought testing back, including MIT, Harvard, Yale, Brown, Dartmouth, Stanford, Caltech, and the University of Texas at Austin, along with public university systems in states like Florida and Georgia. Princeton and Columbia have announced they’ll require scores starting with the 2027-28 application cycle. If your teen’s list includes even one of these schools, testing isn’t optional anymore.
Here’s how I help families make the call.
First, know the four kinds of testing policies
- Test-required: no score, no review. Your teen must submit the SAT or ACT (some colleges also accept the CLT).
- Test-optional: your teen decides whether to send scores. If they do, the college considers them. If they don’t, the college says it won’t hold that against them.
- Test-flexible: a score is required, but AP, IB, or other exams can count in place of the SAT or ACT.
- Test-free (or test-blind): the college won’t look at scores at all, even if you send them. The University of California and California State University systems are test-free.
Policies change every year, sometimes in the middle of a student’s junior year. Always check each college’s admissions website, and use FairTest.org for a broad view of test-optional colleges.
Who should take the SAT or ACT
I recommend testing if any of these describe your teen:
- Their list includes a test-required college, even just one moonshot.
- They’re hoping for merit scholarships. Many scholarship programs, including some at test-optional colleges, still use scores.
- Their school offers few AP, IB, or honors courses, so a strong score can show what their transcript can’t.
- Their GPA doesn’t tell the whole story, because of a rough freshman year, an illness, or a family crisis. A strong score can add context.
- They’re a natural test-taker. If a practice test comes back strong, a little prep can turn that into a real advantage.
Who can reasonably skip it
Some students genuinely don’t need to test. A California student applying only to UC and CSU campuses plus test-optional colleges is the clearest example. So is a student whose practice scores land well below the typical range at every college on their list, and whose time would do more good elsewhere.
That “elsewhere” matters. Serious test prep often takes 40 to 60 hours over a few months. If that time would otherwise go into a meaningful activity, a strong essay, or protecting junior-year grades, skipping the test can be the smarter strategic choice. I give you permission to make that call.
How to decide in the least painful way
Here’s the plan I use with most of my students:
- Take one full-length practice SAT and one practice ACT in 10th grade or early 11th grade, under timed conditions. Both are free online.
- Pick the test that fits. Today’s digital SAT runs about two hours and adapts to the student. The ACT is now about two hours too, with an optional Science section. Most students do noticeably better on one than the other.
- Prep for two to three months, then test in the spring of 11th grade. That leaves summer and early fall for a retake. (Here’s more on when to start studying.)
- Stop at two or three attempts. After that, scores rarely move enough to justify the time.
Should you send your score to a test-optional college?
Look up the college’s middle 50% score range on its admissions website or in its Common Data Set (section C9). Then use my rule of thumb:
- At or above the midpoint: send it. It helps.
- Below the bottom of the range: don’t send it. Let the rest of the application speak.
- In between: it depends on the rest of the application, the student’s school, and the major. That’s a conversation worth having with a counselor.
Your teen can make a different choice at every college. Sending a score to one doesn’t mean sending it to all.
Keep it in perspective
A test score is one piece of an application, and it’s rarely the piece that decides it. Grades in challenging courses, a thoughtful Activities List, and strong essays carry more weight almost everywhere. So test if it makes sense, prepare with a plan, and then put it down. Don’t let the SAT take over junior year.
Free Download
Know when to test, and what comes next
Testing is one deadline among many. My free College Admission Timeline maps out 9th through 12th grade, season by season, so your teen tests at the right time and nothing falls through the cracks.
Send Me the Free Timeline →Free. I’ll send it straight to your inbox.
Keep reading
Robert Powers
Founder, College Torch
Robert Powers is the founder of College Torch, a college counseling practice in Sierra Madre, California, that works with families nationwide. In 10+ years he has guided 300+ students, and 90% go to one of their top three college choices. He holds two degrees from Johns Hopkins, is a Professional Member of IECA, and co-authored a chapter in NACAC’s textbook for college counselors.
IECANACACHECAWACACM.A. Johns Hopkins
Book a free Right-Fit Call | Meet Robert | Parent group on Facebook

