College Torch logo

College Essay Series: Writing the Personal Challenge Essay (UC Prompt #5)

UC Prompt #5 asks about your most significant challenge. Here's how to choose one, keep the problem short, show what you did, and connect it to school.

Students who have started the Personal Statement may already be reflecting on the personal challenges that shaped their high school years. As it turns out, there’s a UC prompt for that too:

“Describe the most significant challenge you have faced and the steps you have taken to overcome this challenge. How has this challenge affected your academic achievement?”

At 350 words, there isn’t much space to do all that. Here are my strategies for the UC5 prompt.

Stressed young man holding his head in his hands at home

What counts as my “most significant” challenge?

Don’t let those words get in your head. You don’t need the hardest challenge ever, or the hardest challenge of anyone you know, or even one everyone else would agree is hard. I give you permission to drop “most” and write about any significant challenge you worked to overcome.

If it matters to you and there’s a story to tell, try writing about it and see how it looks. That said, UC5 should be about a personal challenge. Academic challenges fit better in a UC4 educational barrier essay.

Avoid challenges that aren’t significant enough to do the prompt justice, like missing the school dance, not being allowed to get your driver’s license, or struggling with procrastination. Also avoid challenges that paint you in a negative light or set a negative tone, like a teacher who didn’t like you or classmates talking behind your back.

You have a topic to write about

Many students have one of two reactions to this prompt.

Some immediately dismiss it, feeling they lead either a charmed or a very boring life. I remind these students that no one moves through life without resistance. Nothing comes easily to everyone; if it did, you’d probably have taken over the world by now. What did you set out to do, and (whether you got there or not) what got in the way? What parts of your everyday life do you take for granted that actually demand more of you? Your challenge is likely right under your nose, but you don’t see it because you’ve accepted it as part of life. Brainstorm fully in your journal, and if you don’t like any of the options, move on to a prompt you like better.

Other students have the opposite reaction. They immediately think of a very personal, disruptive challenge, maybe one they’re in the middle of or haven’t shared with anyone yet. That’s understandably overwhelming. I invite these students to breathe, step back, and set that topic aside for a minute. Brainstorm every possible answer. (Remember: a significant challenge is just fine!) As you reflect, you may find the very personal challenge has lost some of its edge and you want to try writing about it. You may decide it’s worth discussing because it’s such a part of who you are. Or you may settle on one of the other challenges, which are perfectly valid for UC5.

Teen in a striped hoodie in front of a colorful mural of a screaming face

Aim for a 20/80 ratio of problem to solution

The number-one pitfall in a UC5 essay is spending too long on the problem. Here’s why that hurts:

  • It sets a negative tone.
  • Dwelling on the problem suggests your head is still stuck in it.
  • It leaves less space to show yourself overcoming the challenge.

Get the problem out fast. Its main job is to set you up to rise out of it. Try to wrap it up in 20% of the essay, about 70 words. You can do it!

Overcoming the challenge is what shows your growth and impresses the reader. Spend as much of the essay as you can detailing exactly how you worked to get over or around it. By the end, the reader should see a story of struggle and (hopefully some) success, not a story about a problem.

Young man submerged up to his eyes in dark water

You don’t need to fully resolve the problem

You can write about an ongoing challenge, as long as the essay follows the advice above. It works as long as you have plenty to say about the struggle, even without a neat solution. List every action you took, effective or not. Tell us whom you asked for help, how, and when. Show how you coped internally, mentally and emotionally, alongside how you fought the challenge externally. This can make an even more engaging essay than one that resolves too easily.

After you write it, check in. Is it negative? Does it dwell on the problem? Does it make you look ineffective? If so, explore other topics and prompts.

Worry about academic achievement last

Because your topic is personal, the essay has a personal journey at its heart. Tackle that first. Once it’s in your outline, consider how the challenge affected your performance in school. A few ways to handle it:

  • Name the negative effect near the beginning, then show how it improved at the end.
  • Or save it all for the end, so the personal story isn’t interrupted.
  • If the challenge explains a low grade or a grade trend (down or up), connect them explicitly.

If the challenge didn’t affect your grades much, or you’re a straight-A student, a sentence on how you kept up your performance despite the trouble works well.

Remember, too, that academic achievement isn’t only tests, projects, and grades. You’re in school to learn. Anytime the challenge kept you from learning your best, retaining information, or applying it in or out of the classroom, you have something to discuss.

Graffiti on a brick wall reading Trust Your Struggle

The previous post in my UC essay series covered UC4, the educational opportunity or barrier prompt. The next covers UC6, the academic interest prompt. You can also see the full series.

Free Download

The UC Essay Planning Guide

To choose your best four PIQs, you need to understand all eight. See what UC readers look for in every prompt.

Get the UC Essay Planning Guide →

Free. I’ll send it straight to your inbox.

Robert Powers

Founder, College Torch

Robert Powers is the founder of College Torch, a college counseling practice in Sierra Madre, California, that works with families nationwide. In 10+ years he has guided 300+ students, and 90% go to one of their top three college choices. He holds two degrees from Johns Hopkins, is a Professional Member of IECA, and co-authored a chapter in NACAC’s textbook for college counselors.

IECANACACHECAWACACM.A. Johns Hopkins

Book a free Right-Fit Call  |  Meet Robert  |  Parent group on Facebook

Share the Post:

Related Posts