College Torch logo

College Essay Series: Writing the Talent or Skill Essay (UC Prompt #3)

UC Prompt #3 isn't about what comes easily. Here's how to choose a skill, start from a real struggle, show your development, and end with a strong after picture.

The number one mistake students make on this essay is showing (or worse, telling about) a talent that has come mostly easily to them. College essays should show change over time, so it’s important to show yourself struggling, improving, and working for your success.

In this installment of my series on all eight Personal Insight Questions from the University of California Application, here’s my advice on the third prompt:

“What would you say is your greatest talent or skill? How have you developed and demonstrated that talent over time?”

Cyclist with a backpack riding an orange bike

Don’t misread the question

The key words in the prompt are “developed” and “demonstrated.” The UCs want you to focus on a skill or talent you worked on over time, got better at, and used for a purpose that matters to you.

  • Developed: The focus should be your improvement. Every personal college essay should show growth over time, but especially this one. It won’t work without a journey of improvement.
  • Demonstrated: The skill should be one you apply. Ideally, those applications become more challenging, relevant, or significant over time.

Don’t get caught up on “greatest talent or skill.” Write about something you do that matters to you, and don’t worry if you’re better at other things. This essay is all about your journey of improvement.

Brainstorm to choose the skill

The prompt doesn’t ask what you’re better at than everyone you know. It doesn’t even ask what you’re good at! Your topic can be anything where you’ve shown improvement, regardless of what the students around you are doing.

Start by listing the areas of your life where you feel confident. Under each, write the individual actions involved. They can be concrete (write, run, code, listen) or more conceptual (empathize, compare, show patience). If an action keeps recurring, or one jumps out as feeling very authentic, consider it as your skill. If an action sounds unusual, keep an open mind. What seems odd at first might be a creative approach to the prompt.

If you have an obvious topic, go for it. If not, a creative answer may win you some points.

Hikers walking through a mossy forest

Start low so you can go high

Would Charlie and the Chocolate Factory have worked if Charlie were wealthy? Would Harry Potter’s first year at Hogwarts have felt as magical if he hadn’t started out living in a cupboard under the stairs? These characters start in rough situations so we can appreciate their journeys. In the same way, you need to show yourself struggling with your skill for part of the essay.

You probably never planned to put your moments of failure in a college essay. But showing a failure, mishap, or embarrassing moment gives the reader a sense of where you started. Then, when you show yourself persisting and getting better, the reader will be impressed by how far you’ve come.

Don’t brag the whole time or focus only on your successes. It doesn’t work!

Development is key

Your development section, where you show how you improved, should be at least 100 of your 350 words. It will probably be longer, and it’s critical to fully answering the prompt.

Start by jotting down as many parts of your development as you can, thinking in action verbs. For a cooking skill, you might have “chop,” “dice,” and “mince.” Break vague verbs like “train” and “practice” into specific verbs that capture exactly what your training involved.

Then put the verbs in order of increasing difficulty. “Chop,” “dice,” and “mince” are probably already in order, but where does “flambé” go? What about the parts that take patience: are they harder or easier? That’s a personal decision, and it helps the reader understand your growth. In the essay, present your development in this order, showing yourself becoming more and more capable.

In film, this sequence is called a montage. A character trains for a big event, gets a makeover, or learns to navigate a new job. Montages are quick, effective, and memorable, and they let a character transform in under sixty seconds. Why not use the same strategy in your college essay?

Student photographer taking pictures in a field of yellow flowers

Show an “after picture”

The end of the essay is your time to be proficient and successful. But don’t just tell the reader how awesome you are; that comes off as bragging. It’s far more effective to describe a full moment where you demonstrate the skill. Give enough detail that the reader can tell the things that once challenged you no longer do. Let us also see how your skill affects your community and the people around you.

Put the three parts together (the struggle, the development, and the after picture), and you’ll show a clear journey of growth into someone with a real talent to share.

Student stretching with arms raised at a laptop in front of bookshelves

The previous post in my UC essay series covered UC2, the creativity prompt. The next covers UC4, the educational opportunity or barrier prompt. You can also see the full series.

Free Download

The UC Essay Planning Guide

To choose your best four PIQs, you need to understand all eight. See what UC readers look for in every prompt.

Get the UC Essay Planning Guide →

Free. I’ll send it straight to your inbox.

Robert Powers

Founder, College Torch

Robert Powers is the founder of College Torch, a college counseling practice in Sierra Madre, California, that works with families nationwide. In 10+ years he has guided 300+ students, and 90% go to one of their top three college choices. He holds two degrees from Johns Hopkins, is a Professional Member of IECA, and co-authored a chapter in NACAC’s textbook for college counselors.

IECANACACHECAWACACM.A. Johns Hopkins

Book a free Right-Fit Call  |  Meet Robert  |  Parent group on Facebook

Share the Post:

Related Posts